Board Thread:General discussion/@comment-2188433-20170510114901/@comment-30711988-20170512201358


 * >Noel not being in the NOL category for example just feels wrong considering she was part of it for over 2 games.

One game, because in CS she's kinda neutral, and in the end sides with Makoto and Tager.
 * >And why make an exemption for Nine?

Because "Six Heroes" is not an organization, it's a title. She was called a hero for saving mankind, no-one said she's not a hero anymore, and no-one undid that act for her to not be called a hero.
 * >By that reasoning categories such as the Ten Sages, the Immortal Breakers and the Six Heroes shouldn't exist

Look above for Six Heroes, and I agree with you on the rest. Sage is a title that indicates magical power, it's important. Breaker is a title that indicates an ability to kill immortals, which is also important. It's not like abandoning either job removes the powers and abilities that allowed them to be a Sage or a Breaker.

As for Organization, it sure looks misleading, but... If someone was a Breaker and then moved on, they still are a Breaker, because they can kill immortals or know how to do that. What about the Organization or the Agency? Did they leave any impact on their former employees?


 * >And Shiori did join that group during the 3rd volume of the manga

Shiori did appear in the 3rd volume of the manga. Let's see... Noel: Shiori became Mai and Kajun's roommate, and with her supertaste, would it be good to tell about Remix Heart's purpose? She didn't say "join Remix Heart", she said "tell about it". And even that was left unanswered, and there's no more mentions of Team Remix Heart in 3rd volume. So, when did Shiori join them?

That's what I dislike about this category. If a person is canonized, they become a Sage. If a person is capable of killing immortals, they are called an Immortal Breaker. If a person develops a crystal, they become a Union. If a person is working for Organization/Agency, they are its employee.

How does one become a part of Remix Heart then? So, I suggest removing the category and leaving the page. Same goes for Sin Architects. Actually, these are even more ambiguous, so seriously, let's leave the page and remove the category.

And Maha Raja's category is also unneeded, since there are only two known people who worked there.